← Scottish dinner and folk music evening on Chambers Street · back to the folk dinner page

The comparison

A folk dinner or the Underground Vaults: which Edinburgh evening?

A seated Scottish supper with live songs set beside a tour of the vaults under the city: format, setting, ratings and who each one suits.

By Edinburgh Folk Dinner Guide · facts last checked

Reserve your evening ↗

Quick answer

Pick the folk dinner if you want to sit, eat and listen; pick the vaults tour if you would rather walk and hear tales of the city's underside. The dinner shows 4.6 from 399 reviews and about US$122 a head; the Underground Vaults tour shows 4.5 from 12,815 reviews and about US$33. They answer different appetites. One is a meal with a piper, two musicians and a whisky toast on Chambers Street, running about three hours, per its page. The other is a guided walk through the stone chambers beneath Edinburgh's bridges, going by its title. Many visitors do both on different nights, since neither needs more than an evening and they do not overlap in what they show.

Supper and vaults, side by side

Folk dinnerUnderground Vaults tour
FormatSeated meal with live folk musicGuided tour of underground vaults, going by its title
LengthAbout three hours, says its pageShown on its own page
Starting fareAbout US$122About US$33
Guest score4.6 across 399 reviews4.5 across 12,815 reviews
SettingA restaurant at 1 Chambers StreetVaults beneath the city, as its page describes
Best forFood, songs and storytellingLocal lore and atmospheric spaces

Two ways to spend one evening

A stone-walled underground chamber lit by a candle sconce, with a dark opening leading on
A candle-lit stone vault in Edinburgh. · Photo: fw42, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Both bookings fill an Edinburgh evening, but they put you in very different places. The supper keeps you at a table in the Old Town, looking at a pair of musicians and a plate of food. The vaults tour moves you through low stone chambers under the city, following a guide. One is a sit-down hospitality experience with a music tradition at its centre; the other is a walking tour whose subject is the city's buried past. If you tried to choose on price alone you would pick the cheaper tour, but a meal, a drink and a performance are not the same product as a tour, so it helps to decide on format first.

What the dinner gives you

The booking page for the folk dinner lists a bagpiper's welcome with photos, a three-course meal of two dishes and a dessert with a complimentary Scottish drink, two musicians playing Scottish folk music from ballads to lively songs and explaining the stories behind them, and a closing whisky toast introduced by an expert. The language is English and the length is about three hours. The restaurant is at 1 Chambers Street. It is, in short, an evening you attend rather than walk through, and the pace is set by courses and songs.

What the vaults tour gives you

The tour's own page carries length, route and meeting point, and none of those is guessed at here. What can be said comes from its title and from Wikipedia's account of the vaults. Wikipedia says the South Bridge was completed in 1788 with nineteen arches, that chambers inside them held taverns, workshops and storage, and that damp and flooding set in early, with abandonment beginning as soon as 1795. The businesses had left by the 1820s, the poorest residents moved in afterwards, and the spaces lay forgotten until they were rediscovered in the 1980s. A tour of this kind trades comfort for atmosphere.

Reading the ratings

The dinner scores 4.6 from 399 reviews; the vaults tour scores 4.5 from 12,815. The vaults number rests on a far larger crowd, which makes it a steadier measure of what a typical visitor thinks, while the dinner's smaller sample comes from a product that draws fewer guests each evening. A tenth of a star is too small to settle anything. What both numbers say is that the large majority of guests are pleased. The difference to weigh is the kind of evening, not the score.

Comfort and pace

The dinner is the gentler option. You are seated for the whole time, someone brings the food, and the performance comes to you. Walking tours of underground spaces involve steps, uneven floors and low ceilings in many places, and the vaults tour's page is the place to check access details for your party. If anyone in your group tires easily, dislikes enclosed spaces or finds stairs difficult, the supper is the more relaxed choice, and the page for the supper is the place to check anything about the venue itself.

What each one teaches you

The folk evening is about living culture: songs, a tradition of storytelling and the Scottish habit of ending a night with a toast. Wikipedia notes that Scottish ballads were passed on by mouth until the 18th century and that a folk revival in the 1950s sent collectors into the field with recorders. The vaults tour is about the city's physical history, how a bridge built in the 1780s left a hidden layer of rooms beneath it. Wikipedia adds a caution that television programmes have claimed ghostly encounters in the vaults but that there is no reliable evidence for them.

The city around both evenings

Both bookings sit in the same medieval district. Wikipedia says the Old Town's narrow ridge and defensive wall pushed builders upward, so tall multi-storey tenements became the norm from the 16th century, and a great fire in 1824 destroyed many of them. The South Bridge, completed in 1788, was part of a later push to bring wider routes across that crowded ground, and Chambers Street was cut through in 1870, removing three 18th-century squares. Seeing the supper and the vaults in the same stay lets you read the district from two angles, the lively surface and the buried layer.

Questions to settle first

Before you book either evening, ask four things. Is everyone in the party comfortable seated for about three hours, and in English? Would anyone struggle with stairs or low, uneven underground spaces? Does a meal and a dram matter more to you than the lowest price? And which would you regret missing? If the answers point to a seat and a plate, book the dinner. If they point to stone and stories, book the tour. If you cannot decide, flip a coin, because both are rated well by thousands of guests.

Who should pick which

Choose the dinner for a birthday, a couple's night out, a family with teenagers who are happy to sit through a meal, or any group that wants to eat well and learn something while doing it. Choose the vaults tour for travellers who want to be moving, who enjoy tales of old Edinburgh and who prefer a lower price and no commitment to a long sitting. If you like both ideas, treat them as two evenings, not rivals, because they cover almost no common ground.

Doing both

A trip of three or four nights has room for both. A sensible order puts the vaults first, while the city is new to you, and keeps the dinner for a later night when you want to sit and unwind. Neither booking needs to be placed on the same date. The dinner's page offers free cancellation, and the vaults tour's page states its own terms. The castle walk with entry and the Highlands day tour on this page fill the daytime on either side.

Booking, in one paragraph

Open the calendar for the supper and the one for the vaults tour, and see which evenings overlap with your plans. The dinner can be cancelled free until the day before, per its page, and the vaults tour's page states its own terms for your date. Whichever you choose, arrange your own transport to the meeting point, check start times in the confirmation e-mail, and book early for weekends.

Frequently asked questions

Which is better value?

They are different products. The vaults tour costs less, while the dinner includes a meal, a drink and live music, so compare what you get rather than the price tag.

Is a double bill possible?

Yes, since they cover different ground; three nights or more leaves each its own evening.

Which suits families?

Check each page for age limits. The dinner is seated and the tour involves walking, so the right choice depends on the children in your group.

Is the vaults tour in the South Bridge vaults?

Its page names the route. Wikipedia describes the best-known vaults as lying inside the arches of South Bridge, but confirm the tour's own details before you book.

Reserve your evening ↗

Sources

  1. The booking page for the Scottish dinner and folk music experience, on GetYourGuide
  2. The booking page for the Underground Vaults tour, on GetYourGuide
  3. Wikipedia: South Bridge Vaults
  4. Wikipedia: Scottish folk music
  5. Wikipedia: Old Town, Edinburgh
  6. Wikipedia: Chambers Street, Edinburgh

More things to do nearby

Reserve your eveningFree cancellation · Reserve now, pay later